What To Know
- In the realm of home and small office printing, the Canon Pixma G3420 and the HP Smart Tank 515 stand out as two of the most popular inkjet printers for their exceptional value and cost-saving features.
- To help you make an informed decision, we’ve put together a head-to-head comparison of the Canon Pixma G3420 and the HP Smart Tank 515, covering their key features, performance, and overall value.
- The Pixma G3420 features a sleek black exterior with a minimalist design, while the Smart Tank 515 has a more rounded shape and a white and blue color scheme.
In the realm of home and small office printing, the Canon Pixma G3420 and the HP Smart Tank 515 stand out as two of the most popular inkjet printers for their exceptional value and cost-saving features. However, choosing between these two printers can be a daunting task, especially if you’re looking for a comprehensive solution that meets your specific printing needs.
To help you make an informed decision, we’ve put together a head-to-head comparison of the Canon Pixma G3420 and the HP Smart Tank 515, covering their key features, performance, and overall value.
Design and Appearance
The Canon Pixma G3420 and HP Smart Tank 515 share a similar compact design, making them ideal for space-conscious areas. However, there are some notable differences in their appearance. The Pixma G3420 features a sleek black exterior with a minimalist design, while the Smart Tank 515 has a more rounded shape and a white and blue color scheme.
Printing Technology and Speed
Both printers use inkjet technology, but they differ in their printing mechanism. The Pixma G3420 employs a traditional cartridge-based system, while the Smart Tank 515 utilizes a refillable ink tank system.
In terms of printing speed, the HP Smart Tank 515 takes the edge. It boasts a print speed of up to 11 pages per minute (ppm) for black and white documents and 5 ppm for color documents. The Pixma G3420, on the other hand, has a slower print speed of 8.8 ppm for black and white documents and 5 ppm for color documents.
Ink Capacity and Cost
One of the key advantages of both printers is their low ink costs. The Pixma G3420 uses high-yield ink cartridges that can print up to 6,000 black pages and 7,000 color pages. The Smart Tank 515, however, offers even more significant savings with its refillable ink tanks. Each set of ink bottles can print up to 18,000 black pages and 8,000 color pages.
When comparing the cost per page, the HP Smart Tank 515 emerges as the clear winner. It has an estimated cost per page of just 1 cent for black and white documents and 5 cents for color documents. The Pixma G3420 has a slightly higher cost per page of 1.7 cents for black and white documents and 8.3 cents for color documents.
Connectivity and Features
Both the Canon Pixma G3420 and HP Smart Tank 515 offer a range of connectivity options, including Wi-Fi, USB, and mobile printing. The Smart Tank 515 has an additional advantage with Bluetooth connectivity, allowing you to print directly from your smartphone or tablet.
In terms of features, the Smart Tank 515 has a slight edge. It comes with a built-in automatic document feeder (ADF) for scanning and copying multiple pages at once. The Pixma G3420 does not have an ADF, but it offers a rear paper tray for printing on thicker paper types.
Print Quality
Both printers deliver excellent print quality for everyday printing tasks. The Pixma G3420 produces sharp and vibrant text and graphics, while the Smart Tank 515 excels in printing photos with accurate colors and smooth transitions.
Overall Value
When it comes to overall value, the HP Smart Tank 515 emerges as the better choice. It offers a lower cost per page, faster printing speeds, a wider range of connectivity options, and a built-in ADF. While the Pixma G3420 has a slightly higher cost per page and slower printing speeds, it may be a more suitable option if you require printing on thicker paper types.
The Verdict: HP Smart Tank 515
Based on our comprehensive comparison, the HP Smart Tank 515 is the clear winner for budget-friendly printing with its exceptional value, low ink costs, and versatile features. It’s an ideal choice for homes, small offices, and anyone looking for a high-quality printer without breaking the bank.
Top Questions Asked
Q: Which printer has the lower cost per page?
A: The HP Smart Tank 515 has a lower cost per page than the Canon Pixma G3420.
Q: Which printer offers faster printing speeds?
A: The HP Smart Tank 515 has faster printing speeds than the Canon Pixma G3420.
Q: Which printer has a built-in ADF?
A: The HP Smart Tank 515 has a built-in ADF, while the Canon Pixma G3420 does not.
Q: Which printer can print on thicker paper types?
A: The Canon Pixma G3420 offers a rear paper tray for printing on thicker paper types, while the HP Smart Tank 515 does not.
Q: Which printer has a more compact design?
A: Both printers have a similar compact design, but the Canon Pixma G3420 is slightly smaller.
